The Pros and Cons of Refinancing a Home Explained

Your home is likely your biggest financial asset, but it’s more than just a number on paper. It holds real value you can use to achieve your goals. Whether you want to fund a new business, pay for a child’s education, or finally build that backyard deck, refinancing can turn your home’s equity into cash. It’s a strategic financial move that can unlock new possibilities. However, it also comes with costs and considerations that need to be weighed carefully. Before you start an application, it’s essential to understand the full picture of the pros and cons of refinancing a home to ensure it aligns with your long-term financial plan.

Key Takeaways

• Match your mortgage to your current life: Refinancing is a tool to update your home loan to fit your present financial situation, whether your goal is to lower monthly payments, access cash for a large expense, or consolidate other debts.
• Weigh the costs against the savings: A lower payment is appealing, but refinancing has upfront costs like legal and appraisal fees. Calculate your break-even point to ensure you'll stay in your home long enough for the long-term savings to outweigh the initial expense.
• Consider alternatives before you commit: A full refinance isn't your only option. A Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) or a second mortgage can help you access equity without replacing your entire mortgage, which can be ideal if you already have a great interest rate.

What Is Home Refinancing and How Does It Work?

Think of refinancing as trading in your current mortgage for a new one. When you refinance, you’re essentially getting a new home loan to pay off your existing one, but the goal is to get a better deal that fits your current life. The new loan might come with a different interest rate, a new monthly payment, or a different repayment schedule. For many Ontario homeowners, it’s a strategic way to lower monthly payments, access home equity for a big project like a renovation, or consolidate other debts into a single, more manageable payment.

Your life and financial goals can change a lot over the term of a mortgage, and refinancing allows your home loan to change with you. It’s not just about chasing the lowest interest rate; it’s about structuring your finances in a way that supports your goals, whether that’s becoming debt-free faster or freeing up cash for an investment. A mortgage brokerage can help you explore different lenders and products to find a solution that works for your unique situation, saving you the time of shopping around on your own.

The Refinancing Process in Ontario

The refinancing process in Ontario is pretty straightforward. It starts with taking a look at your current financial picture and your goals. You’ll want to figure out how much equity you have in your home and what your credit score looks like. From there, you can start exploring new mortgage options. This is where working with a licensed mortgage expert can be a huge help, as they can compare offers from various lenders on your behalf.

Once you choose a lender and a product, you’ll submit a formal application with documents like proof of income and property tax statements. The lender will likely require a home appraisal to confirm your property’s current market value. If everything is approved, you’ll work with a real estate lawyer to close the deal. They’ll handle paying off your old mortgage with the funds from the new one and registering the new loan on your property’s title. The whole process can often be completed in just a few weeks.

Key Terms You Should Know

As you explore refinancing, you’ll come across a few key terms. Closing costs are the fees you pay to finalize the new loan. It’s a common myth that refinancing is free; these costs can include legal fees, appraisal fees, and title insurance, so it’s important to factor them into your decision. Another term is a prepayment penalty, which is a fee your current lender might charge if you pay off your mortgage before the end of your term. Be sure to check your original mortgage documents for this.

You’ll also hear about your credit score, which lenders use to assess your financial health. Applying for a new loan will result in a hard inquiry on your credit report, which can cause your score to dip slightly for a short time. Finally, the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio is the percentage of your home’s value that is being financed. In Canada, you can typically only refinance up to 80% of your home’s appraised value.

The Pros: Top Reasons to Refinance Your Home

Refinancing your mortgage can feel like a big step, but it’s one of the most powerful financial tools available to a homeowner. It’s more than just swapping out your old mortgage for a new one; it’s an opportunity to realign your home financing with your current financial reality and future goals. Life changes, and the mortgage that was perfect for you five years ago might not be the best fit today. Whether you’re looking to reduce your monthly expenses, fund a major life event, or simplify your debts, refinancing can provide the flexibility you need.

Many homeowners choose to refinance when their financial picture has improved—maybe you’ve received a promotion or your credit score has gone up. Others are motivated by favourable market conditions, like a drop in interest rates. Think of it as a chance to get a better deal on the biggest loan you’ll likely ever have. It’s a strategic move that can improve your monthly cash flow and help you achieve your long-term ambitions. Let’s walk through some of the most common and compelling reasons why refinancing might be the right move for you.

Lower Your Monthly Payments

One of the most popular reasons to refinance is to secure a lower interest rate. If the Bank of Canada’s interest rates have dropped since you first got your mortgage, or if your credit score has improved, you may qualify for a rate that significantly reduces your monthly payment. This can free up hundreds of dollars in your budget each month, giving you more breathing room for savings, investments, or other expenses. Even a small rate reduction can add up to thousands of dollars in savings over the life of your loan, making it a powerful way to improve your cash flow.

Access Your Home's Equity

As you pay down your mortgage and your property value increases, you build home equity. Refinancing is a common way to tap into that value and turn it into cash. With a cash-out refinance, you replace your current mortgage with a new, larger one, and you receive the difference in cash. Homeowners often use these funds to pay for major expenses like a home renovation, a child’s university education, or to invest in a business. It allows you to leverage the value of your home to fund important life goals without taking on higher-interest unsecured loans.

Consolidate High-Interest Debt

If you’re juggling multiple high-interest debts like credit card balances, lines of credit, or personal loans, refinancing can be a smart way to simplify your finances. By using a consolidation loan to pay off these debts, you can roll everything into a single mortgage payment at a much lower interest rate. This not only makes your monthly bills easier to manage but can also save you a substantial amount of money on interest charges. For many homeowners, this strategy is the key to getting out of debt faster and taking control of their financial health.

Switch to a Fixed-Rate Mortgage

If you have a variable-rate mortgage, your payments can fluctuate as interest rates change, which can create uncertainty in your budget. Refinancing allows you to switch to a fixed-rate mortgage, locking in a consistent interest rate and payment for the entire term. This predictability can provide valuable peace of mind, especially in a volatile economic climate. You can also adjust your loan term when you refinance—for example, switching from a 25-year to a 15-year amortization to pay off your home faster and save on total interest paid.

The Cons: Potential Downsides to Consider

Refinancing can be a fantastic financial tool, but it’s not the right move for every homeowner. Before you jump in, it’s important to look at the complete picture and understand the potential drawbacks. Thinking through these points will help you decide if the benefits truly outweigh the costs for your specific situation. From upfront fees to long-term interest, let's walk through the key considerations to keep in mind.

Closing Costs and Other Fees

Just like when you got your original mortgage, refinancing comes with closing costs. These are the fees you pay to finalize the new loan. In Ontario, they can include legal fees, an appraisal fee to confirm your home's current value, and potentially a discharge fee for your old mortgage. These costs can add up, so it's crucial to calculate your "break-even point." This is the moment when the savings from your new, lower payment have completely covered the initial closing costs. If you plan to sell your home before you reach that point, refinancing might end up costing you more than it saves.

A Longer Loan Term Can Mean More Interest

One of the main attractions of refinancing is a lower monthly payment, which is often achieved by extending your loan's amortization period. For example, if you have 15 years left on your mortgage, you might refinance into a new 25-year loan. While this will almost certainly reduce your payments, it also means you'll be paying interest for an extra 10 years. Over the life of the loan, you could end up paying significantly more in total interest. It’s a trade-off: more cash in your pocket each month versus a higher overall cost for your home.

Prepayment Penalties on Your Current Mortgage

If you're in the middle of a mortgage term (especially a fixed-rate one), your current lender may charge a prepayment penalty for paying it off early. This fee can be substantial, sometimes amounting to thousands of dollars. Before you get too far into the refinancing process, dig up your original mortgage documents or contact your lender to find out if a penalty applies. Understanding this potential cost is essential, as a large penalty could easily wipe out any savings you’d gain from a lower interest rate.

Meeting Qualification Requirements

When you refinance, you’re essentially applying for a brand-new loan, which means you have to qualify all over again. Lenders will review your financial situation, including your credit score, your income, and your overall debt load. In Canada, you'll also need to pass the mortgage stress test. If your financial circumstances have changed since you first bought your home—for instance, if you've become self-employed or taken on more debt—you might find it more challenging to get approved. It’s a good idea to get a clear picture of your financial standing before you start an application.

Is Refinancing the Right Move for You?

Deciding whether to refinance your mortgage is a major financial decision, and what works for one homeowner might not be the right fit for another. While the potential for a lower interest rate or more manageable monthly payment is appealing, it’s important to look at the complete picture. The best choice for you depends entirely on your personal finances, your long-term goals, and your plans for the future.

Before you jump in, take some time to think through a few key questions. How much will it cost to refinance? What are you hoping to achieve by changing your mortgage terms? And how long do you see yourself living in your current home? Answering these questions honestly will help you determine if the benefits of refinancing truly outweigh the costs. Think of it as creating a personal roadmap to ensure your mortgage continues to work for you, not against you. Let’s walk through the essential factors to consider.

Calculate Your Break-Even Point

Your break-even point is the moment you’ve paid off the costs of refinancing with the money you’re saving each month. To find it, you simply divide your total closing costs by your monthly savings. For example, if your refinancing costs are $3,000 and your new mortgage saves you $150 per month, your break-even point is 20 months ($3,000 ÷ $150). This means it will take you one year and eight months to recoup the initial expense. After that, the savings are all yours. This simple calculation is a powerful tool for seeing if a refinance makes sense in the long run.

Review Your Current Financial Goals

Refinancing isn’t just about securing a lower rate. It’s a strategic tool that can help you achieve a variety of financial goals. Are you looking to free up monthly cash flow for other expenses or investments? Or maybe you want to pay off your home faster by switching to a shorter loan term. Perhaps your goal is to tap into your home’s equity to fund a major renovation, start a business, or consolidate high-interest debts into one lower-interest payment. By clarifying what you want to accomplish, you can ensure that the refinancing option you choose aligns perfectly with your overall financial plan.

Consider How Long You Plan to Stay

Your break-even point is most meaningful when you consider it alongside your future plans. If you think you might sell your home in the next few years, refinancing may not be the best move. For instance, if your break-even point is three years away but you plan to move in two, you’ll end up losing money because you won’t have stayed long enough to recover the closing costs. Be realistic about your timeline. If you’re settled in for the long haul, refinancing is more likely to pay off. But if a move is potentially on the horizon, you’ll want to weigh the costs very carefully.

Weigh the Costs Against the Savings

While the idea of a lower monthly payment is attractive, it’s crucial to remember that refinancing isn’t free. You’ll need to account for various closing costs, which can include legal fees, an appraisal fee, and potentially a prepayment penalty from your current lender for breaking your mortgage term early. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada offers helpful information on how these penalties are calculated. It’s also important to look at the total interest you’ll pay over the life of the new loan. If you extend your loan term, you could end up paying more in interest over time, even with a lower rate. Make sure the long-term savings truly justify the upfront expense.

Common Refinancing Myths, Busted

Refinancing can feel like a big step, and it’s easy to get overwhelmed by all the advice out there. A lot of what you hear might be outdated or just plain wrong. Let's clear up some of the most common myths so you can make a decision that feels right for you and your financial future.

Myth: Refinancing Is Always a Good Idea

While refinancing can be a fantastic tool for lowering your payments or tapping into your home’s equity, it isn’t a guaranteed win for every homeowner. The best choice really depends on your unique situation. For example, if you plan on selling your home in the next year or two, the closing costs could cancel out any savings from a lower interest rate. It’s important to weigh the upfront costs against the long-term benefits and make sure the timing aligns with your personal financial goals. Refinancing is a strategic move, not an automatic upgrade.

Myth: You Need Perfect Credit to Qualify

This is one of the biggest misconceptions that stops people from exploring their options. While a high credit score certainly helps you get the most competitive rates from traditional lenders, it’s not the only factor they consider. Lenders also look at your income, your property’s value, and the amount of equity you have. Plus, different lenders have different requirements. At Lotly, we work with a variety of lenders, including those who specialize in helping homeowners with non-traditional income or those who are rebuilding their credit history. You have more options than you might think.

Myth: The Lowest Rate Is Always the Best Deal

It’s tempting to focus only on the interest rate, but the lowest number doesn’t always equal the best deal. A mortgage with a rock-bottom rate could come with hefty closing costs, inflexible terms, or significant prepayment penalties if you decide to pay it off early. It’s crucial to look at the whole picture. Consider the fees, the length of the term, and any other conditions attached to the loan. A slightly higher rate on a mortgage with lower fees and more flexibility might actually save you more money in the long run. Always review the full mortgage agreement before signing.

Myth: The Process Is Too Complicated

I get it—the thought of more paperwork can be daunting. But refinancing doesn't have to be a headache. While there are several steps involved, like submitting documents and getting a home appraisal, the process is much more straightforward when you have someone guiding you. Working with a licensed mortgage expert means you have a partner to walk you through every stage, answer your questions, and handle the details. The process is designed to be thorough, but it’s completely manageable with the right support. You can even get started in minutes with a simple online application.

Exploring Your Options: Alternatives to Refinancing

Refinancing can be a powerful tool, but it’s not your only choice for adjusting your mortgage or accessing your home’s value. Depending on your financial goals, another path might make more sense. Maybe you want to fund a renovation without touching your great interest rate, or perhaps your mortgage term is ending and you're wondering what's next. Understanding the alternatives helps you make a confident, informed decision that fits your life. Let's look at a few common options available to Ontario homeowners.

Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs)

A Home Equity Line of Credit, or HELOC, is a flexible way to borrow against your home's equity. Think of it like a credit card secured by your property. You get approved for a specific credit limit and can withdraw funds as you need them, repay the balance, and borrow again. This makes a HELOC a great fit for ongoing projects with unpredictable costs, like a kitchen remodel or covering post-secondary education fees. You only pay interest on the money you actually use, which can make it a cost-effective choice for managing cash flow.

Second Mortgages and Home Equity Loans

If you need a large sum of money for a specific purpose, a second mortgage could be the right fit. This is a separate loan taken out on your property in addition to your existing mortgage. A home equity loan is a common type of second mortgage where you receive the full loan amount in one lump sum. It’s ideal for big, one-time expenses like consolidating high-interest debts or making a down payment on an investment property. You’ll make regular, fixed payments over a set term, which makes budgeting straightforward. This option lets you access equity without disturbing the favourable rate on your primary mortgage.

Renewing vs. Refinancing: What's the Difference?

These terms are often used interchangeably, but they mean very different things. Renewing your mortgage happens at the end of your term. It’s the process of signing on for another term with your current lender. Usually, the loan amount and remaining amortization period stay the same—you’re just agreeing to a new interest rate and term. Refinancing, on the other hand, means replacing your existing mortgage with a completely new one. You can do this with your current lender or a new one, and it allows you to change key features, like borrowing more money or extending your amortization period.

Ready to Refinance? Here Are Your Next Steps

If you’ve weighed the pros and cons and decided that refinancing is the right move, the next phase is all about taking action. Getting organized can make the process feel much smoother and help you secure the best possible deal for your financial situation. Think of it as a three-part plan: doing your homework, understanding what lenders are looking for, and then putting together a strong application. Each step builds on the last, setting you up for a successful outcome. Let's walk through what you need to do to get started.

Shop for the Best Rates and Terms

It’s tempting to jump on the first good offer you see, but taking the time to compare your options can save you thousands over the life of your loan. Don’t just focus on the interest rate; look at the entire package. This includes the loan term, any associated fees, and the flexibility of the prepayment privileges. Getting quotes from several different lenders will give you a clear picture of what’s available. A mortgage brokerage can be a huge help here, as they work with multiple lenders—from traditional to alternative—to find a solution that fits your specific needs, saving you the legwork of approaching each one individually.

Understand Ontario's Lender Requirements

When you apply to refinance, lenders in Ontario will look at your overall financial health to assess their risk. They typically focus on your income, your credit history, and your property's value. While every lender has slightly different criteria, most will review your credit score and report from a Canadian credit bureau like Equifax or TransUnion. They'll also calculate your debt service ratios (GDS and TDS) to see how your housing costs and total debt load compare to your income. Don't worry if you don't fit the traditional mould; many lenders offer flexible options for homeowners who are self-employed or have non-standard income streams.

Start Your Refinancing Application

Once you’re ready to move forward, you’ll need to gather some key documents. This usually includes proof of income (like pay stubs or tax assessments), details about your existing mortgage, and a recent property tax bill. Before you officially apply, it’s a great idea to calculate your break-even point. You can do this by dividing your total closing costs by your expected monthly savings. This tells you how many months it will take for the refinance to pay for itself. When you have your documents and your numbers sorted, you can confidently begin your application and take the next step toward your financial goals.

Related Articles

• Mortgage refinancing 101: What it is & why you might consider doing it
• HELOC rates in Canada: complete guide for homeowners (2025)
• How much are closing costs in Ontario & what should I budget?
• Reverse mortgages, explained: A simple guide for homeowners
• How to calculate a reverse mortgage (a crash course)

Frequently Asked Questions

How will refinancing affect my credit score? When you apply to refinance, lenders will perform a "hard inquiry" on your credit report, which can cause a small, temporary dip in your score. However, the long-term impact is often positive. If you use the refinance to consolidate high-interest debts, you can simplify your payments and lower your overall credit utilization, which can help improve your score over time.

Can I still refinance if I'm self-employed or my income isn't consistent? Yes, you absolutely can. While traditional lenders often prefer a standard employment history, many lenders specialize in working with homeowners who have non-traditional income streams. As a mortgage brokerage, we connect you with these lenders who look at your complete financial picture, not just your last two pay stubs, to find a solution that works for you.

What's the real difference between renewing my mortgage and refinancing it? Think of renewing as simply extending your agreement with your current lender at the end of your term, usually with a new interest rate. Refinancing is different because it involves replacing your old mortgage with a brand-new one. This gives you the flexibility to change the loan amount, the repayment schedule, or even the lender to better suit your current financial goals.

How much should I budget for refinancing costs? The costs can vary, but you should generally plan for legal fees, an appraisal fee to determine your home's current value, and potentially a prepayment penalty if you're breaking your current mortgage term early. It's important to get a clear estimate of these costs upfront so you can calculate your break-even point and ensure the long-term savings make the initial expense worthwhile.

Should I get a home equity line of credit (HELOC) instead of refinancing? It really depends on your goal. A HELOC is great if you need flexible, ongoing access to cash for things like a renovation where costs might change. You only pay interest on what you use. A cash-out refinance is better suited for when you need a large, single lump sum of money for a specific purpose, like consolidating all your debts into one payment.